Framed by the quiet ritual of scrolling through comments on a midnight screen, it’s easy to forget how much patience and care goes into niche communities. Collectors swap wrist shots and trade tips—small moments that build trust over time. In that space, no detail is too minor, and authenticity becomes the currency that binds strangers as peers. Today, that very authenticity faces a new test: balancing a leading watch publication with a fledgling e-commerce arm buffeted by shifting US tariffs. Robert-Jan founded Fratello as a personal watch blog in 2004, drawn by his own collector’s curiosity. Two decades later, that curiosity has expanded into an editorial team of fifteen, a suite of podcasts and videos—and a side business of co-branded watch collaborations born from trial and error on e-commerce solutions. 

“We started with stories—e-commerce came later.”

From trial and error with suppliers and Shopify to navigating tariff-driven dips in US orders, the operations of adding a retail arm forced a hard lesson: “Being a retailer in watches means you need to sell complete collections of watches while we are catering towards a niche of watch collectors and watch enthusiasts,” he explains. Faced with the reality that full-line retail demanded resources Fratello didn’t have, the team pivoted to limited-edition collaborations: designing a special dial or strap with established brands and selling exclusively through their shop. That inflection point shifted e-commerce from a generic retailer role into a branded, co-creative partnership—one that supports marketing goals as much as revenue.

‍

“We don’t want to be an extension of their marketing department—I’d lose credibility. Instead, we help brands tell their story and measure every click.”

Building on Content, Community, and Marketing
While publication remains Fratello’s primary revenue pillar through media partnerships and advertising, content drives every channel—from podcasts to newsletters. The weekly podcasts,Fratello Talks and Fratello on Air, reach engaged listeners who already trust Fratello’s authenticity. With a 50 percent newsletter open rate and self-moderating comment sections, the platform measures true engagement rather than vanity metrics. “If you want people to buy something, I think newsletters are still the number one that works great,” Robert-Jan notes. Fratello realized early on that diversifying into topics—from sub-€3,000 watches to microbrands—can easily double traffic, showing that clear audience insight guides both editorial and commercial decisions. 

Today, Fratello’s content ecosystem feeds its e-commerce and advertising models: every article, podcast, or video is an opportunity to connect readers with brands. By keeping content creation fully in-house—from photography to editing—the team maintains credibility, even as it sells co-branded accessories and limited-edition watches.

Finally, Fratello faces the same slow luxury market headwinds as its partners. Yet Robert-Jan remains focused on what brought him here: “In uncertain times, people do not spend on luxury. All we can do is stay positive, find synergies with brands, and keep our community engaged.” That mindset reflects a company still rooted in the small, shared moments that first sparked a blog—and now drives a resilient, two-pillar business.

‍